For my country based research project I am going to take an in depth look at how the history of Turkey and its attempt at assimilation into the culture of Europe, has influenced the formation of engineering practices.
In large part the formation of Turkey's engineering education was in response to the Ottoman Empire's loss of power as the nations of Europe rose in world power in the 17th and 18th centuries. The French model of engineering highly influenced the blueprint of Turkish engineering, for example French became a required language in the military schools! After World War I the Ottoman lands were divided among the nations of Europe, increasing Europe's influence on Turkey. However soon after Turkey fought for its Independence and became the first republic in the Middle East in 1923. Quickly moving through its history, after World War II, the number of engineering students in Turkey continued to grow and therefore more and more universities were being established. One specific term I will be discussing in this project in the concept of liberalization. In the 1970's Turkey experienced one of its worst economic crisis, which included high inflation and unemployment rates. However what occurred consequently benefited the country exponentially. The government began a process of liberalizing the economy, which meant the economic focus became exporting instead of importing. The results of this shift in focus included, modernization in infrastructure (bridges, roads, etc. which calls for more engineers!) and an explosion of universities. These historical events play a prominent role in the development of engineering education. Turkey was prompted by Europe to engage in advancement for its engineers, but was also highly influenced by European methods, especially the French.
Another unique characteristic of engineering practices in Turkey is the inclusion of women in the engineering work force. After the establishment of the Republic, the government installed a series of legislation to "modernize" Turkey and the head of the country thought that reforms which gave women more rights was crucial. This not only paved the way for women in engineering but, began with a series of legislation to give women social rights. By 1930 women were given full political rights.
The European influence on Turkey has led the country to apply for acceptance into the European Union. Turkey's history as a former territory of the multiethnic Ottoman Empire sets it apart from the rest of its primary Islamic neighbors and its possible assimilation into the European Union would set it apart even more. I would like to examine how Europe influenced Turkey's engineering practices and how its movement towards European practices affects society as well. Turkey is a unique case because its engineering history includes the progressive notion of advancement of women in the field of engineering, which sets it a part from the engineering model of Europe. In an article by IEEE Technology and Society Magazine 2006, they examine "how the emergence of the engineering profession in different locations in the world tends to depend upon local ideas of societal development and progress…Because distinct images of progress are taken up within different countries, becoming key features of national identities, the emergence of the engineering profession becomes a key constituent feature of emerging nation states" (9). Therefore in this report I will look at how the engineering practices of Turkey have been formed by a conglomeration of ideas from Turkish society but also those of European societies. I will look into the question of whether this mix of engineering practices has addressed the needs of the Turkish people or whether it was simply a replication of that which was done in Europe.
Tantekin-Ersolmaz, S. Birgul and Ekinci Ekrem. "Engineering and Education Practices in Turkey" IEEE Society and Technology Magazine. Summer 2006: 26-35.
This is an interesting perspective on Turkey. Being on the cusp on the Asian and European continents, Turkey has always been a country of multiple influences, from the Kingdom of Byzantium to the current secular government. I am not surprised that Turkey would have some of the most advanced engineers in the world because of their history with the Roman Empire and their military prominence.
ReplyDeleteI like how you said it was an export based economic decision that lead to infrastructure building. We in America could learn a thing or two from this belief in infrastructure as a way to spur economic growth. The Turks used the well-known and successful French method in their education which allowed them to produce many Engineers in a short amount of time. I am curious if Turkish engineers learn the same thing as American engineers.
Jackie, I am so glad that you are looking at Turkey for your analysis. One of your biggest challenges will be figuring out exactly which topic you want to centralize in your analysis.
ReplyDeleteI am, of course, very interested in the status of women in engineering in Turkey. Later in our new module, we will be looking at Norway as an "exception" to the underrepresentation of women in STEM fields in Europe. Turkey is often identified as a second "exceptional" country, and this, in large part, seems to be an accurate representation (Alice E. Smith and Berna Dengiz (2009)."Women in engineering in Turkey – a large scale quantitative and qualitative examination," European Journal of Engineering Education). I believe that women are also "overrepresented" in physics in Turkey, although I believe that this is often explained by the relative de-valuing of physics as a discipline in Turkey (in contrast to the hyper-valuing of physics in the U.S. for example). It might be useful, if you pursue this part of the topic, to tie in attention to the status of engineering and the number and experiences of women engineers (for example, how much are engineers paid, what is their unemployment rate, etc.).
Another way to approach the project might be to look at why Turkey wants to join the EU, and what the objections of EU countries are to this. Where do engineering and industry fit in the objections, for example? I think this exploration may also allow you to explore questions such as "what does it mean to be western?" and "what does it mean to be developed?" - perhaps talking with Mandy or Vanessa may be useful here, as I believe they are both focusing on indigenous technologies / alternative models of development.
It might also be useful to talk to Daisy about her research on engineering in Egypt - clearly, very different situations, but one thread to explore may be to explore whether/if/how Islam (and/or nationalism) plays a role in the development of engineering education and practice?
Too, another frame might focus on what it means to be "multi-ethnic" in Turkey vs. (for example) in the U.S. - and how that might shape/not shape engineering education and practice.